Architecture & development economics
Refurbishment versus retention
Retention cash flows: [0, 600k, 600k, 600k]. Refurbishment: [-900k, 420k, 840k, 840k]. Undiscounted incremental cash flow over three years is -SAR 600k.…

Assume an existing income asset with annual net operating cash flow of SAR 600k before financing and tax if retained, versus SAR 840k after refurbishment. Immediate capex SAR 900k, six months of first-year downtime, three-year horizon and 8% annual discount rate; no terminal value, disposal or rent growth.
Retention cash flows: [0, 600k, 600k, 600k]. Refurbishment: [-900k, 420k, 840k, 840k]. Undiscounted incremental cash flow over three years is -SAR 600k. Retention NPV ≈ SAR 1,546,258; refurbishment NPV ≈ SAR 875,873; incremental NPV ≈ -SAR 670,386. The equal-NPV immediate capex ceiling is approximately SAR 229,614. This is a scenario limit, not an asset valuation or contractor quote.
Decision: refurbishment fails this particular three-year incremental comparison despite a 40% increase in stabilised operating cash flow. A longer holding period or evidenced residual value could change the conclusion. Verify technical condition, hidden enabling works, permissions, achievable rents and contractor quotations before a real decision.
